Commissioning and integrated systems testing: the liability

Commissioning is how a data center owner finds out whether the redundancy on the drawings actually works. That makes the commissioning agent’s reports the evidence everyone relies on, and the first thing everyone reads after an outage.

How it is done

The five levels of data center commissioning

Data center commissioning is usually described in five levels, from factory testing to integrated systems testing (IST).[1][2] Some firms number the stages from 0 to 6, with design review at the start, but integrated testing still sits at Level 5.[1]

01

Level 1: factory testing

Major equipment is tested at the factory before it ships, with the commissioning agent often witnessing.

02

Level 2: installation checks

On site, equipment is checked against the drawings and the manufacturer’s requirements before it is energized.

03

Level 3: start up

Each piece of equipment is started and tested on its own.

04

Level 4: system testing

Equipment is tested together as a system: a generator plant, a UPS system, a chilled water loop.

05

Level 5: integrated systems testing

The whole facility is run through normal and failure scenarios, including a simulated utility loss, under load.

Level 5

What integrated systems testing proves, and what it does not

IST is sometimes called pulling the plug. The facility is put through normal and failure scenarios, such as a utility outage, an equipment failure or a single point challenge, at several load levels, and the team checks that generators start, transfer switches operate and the UPS carries the load in between.[2][1]

Because the servers are not installed yet, the load comes from load banks: equipment that simulates the electrical and thermal load of a full data hall so power and cooling can be tested before live IT is at risk.[4][3] Liquid cooled load banks are used to test the liquid cooling systems built for AI and high performance computing.[4] A typical sequence runs the hall at full simulated load, then transfers the building’s power to confirm the UPS carries it without interruption and the generators start in time.[5][3]

Our practical view: IST proves the scenarios in the script, on the day, at the loads tested. It does not prove scenarios nobody wrote down. When a system fails a year later, the first question is usually whether that failure was in the script. The second is who wrote and approved the script.

After a failure

Who is liable when a system fails after IST

There is no single answer. It depends on the contracts and the facts, and the commissioning agent is rarely alone. Our practical view of the usual questions: Was the failure a design problem, an installation problem, an equipment defect or an operating error? Did the commissioning scope include the scenario that failed? Did the agent report what it saw accurately? Did anyone accept a failed or skipped test and move on?

What the agent signs matters as much as what it tests. A report that says a system was “tested and witnessed per the approved script, with these exceptions” is a description of work done. A certificate that says a system “will perform” is closer to a guarantee, and liability you take on by contract beyond what the law would impose is commonly excluded by professional liability policies.[9]

Contract roles

Owner’s agent or contractor’s agent

Guidance from state energy programs and commissioning bodies favors an independent commissioning agent under contract to the owner, to keep the testing unbiased and avoid conflicts of interest.[6][7] On fast data center projects, agents are also hired by the general contractor or the design builder.

Neither model is wrong, but they produce different claims. An owner’s agent is relied on by the owner and can be blamed by the owner for missing something. A contractor’s agent can be accused by the owner of having had a reason not to find it. Whichever you are, the contract should say who you report to, what you verify, and that you do not supervise the contractor’s means and methods.

Insurance

Three policies, three different questions

Professional liability is for claims that your commissioning work was negligent: a missed deficiency, a wrong conclusion, a test script that left out a failure mode. HUB International, a broker, warns that when services go beyond the contracted scope, the work can fall outside the insured scope, and that the policy should track what a firm actually does.[8] Commissioning scopes grow during closeout. Tell your broker.

General liability is for injury to people and damage to other people’s property. On a site where load banks are generating heat and switching is live, it is not a formality.

Builder’s risk covers the project itself while it is built, usually bought by the owner or contractor. EPIC, a broker, notes that many builder’s risk policies carry restrictions, exclusions or sublimits once systems are energized or tested, and that delays during testing can arrive exactly when coverage narrows.[10] Some policies end coverage on connection to utilities or the start of operational testing, and testing and commissioning endorsements exist to extend it.[11] HUB notes that builder’s risk ends and the operational property program has to be bound before the facility goes live, and flags the window around substantial completion as a period where gaps appear.[12]

Before Level 5

Six questions to settle

  1. Who hired you, and whose interests does your contract say you represent?
  2. Does your scope say you witness, verify and report, or does it say you certify that systems will perform?
  3. Who writes the test scripts, and who approves them before Level 5?
  4. Who controls the load banks and the switching during testing, and who is on site with authority to stop a test?
  5. When does the builder’s risk policy end, and what does it say about testing, energization and hot commissioning?
  6. Is commissioning described on your professional liability application as a professional service?
For your firm

Is commissioning on your application?

If your policy does not know you commission data centers, a claim is the wrong time to find out. Send us your application and we will check how your services are described.

Common questions

Commissioning liability, in plain words

Does passing integrated systems testing protect the commissioning agent?

Not by itself. Testing shows the systems performed in the scenarios tested on the day. If a later failure traces to a scenario the scripts left out, or to a result that was reported as passing when it was not, the question becomes whether the agent met the standard of care under its contract.

Is commissioning covered by professional liability insurance?

Many professional liability policies can cover commissioning, but it depends on the policy wording and on how your services are described. A broker has noted that work beyond the scope a policy was told about can fall outside it, so describe commissioning, and any data center work, on your application.

If a load bank test damages equipment, which policy responds?

It depends on the facts and the wording. Damage to the project under construction is usually a builder’s risk question, and brokers warn that many builder’s risk policies restrict or end coverage once systems are energized or tested. Injury or damage to other people’s property is a general liability question.

Should the commissioning agent work for the owner or the contractor?

Industry guidance favors an agent retained directly by the owner and independent of the design and construction teams. When the agent works for the contractor, the contract should say plainly what it does and does not verify for the owner.

Keep reading

Related

Sources

  1. Hioki, “Data Center Commissioning and 5 Levels of Testing” (a test instrument maker)
  2. Data Foundry, “What Does It Mean to Commission a Data Center?” (a data center operator)
  3. Sunbelt Solomon, “Data Center Commissioning 101: Validating Critical Power Systems With Load Banks” (an equipment vendor)
  4. Trane, “What Is a Load Bank?” (an HVAC manufacturer)
  5. Aggreko, “Load bank testing and commissioning key to data center performance” (a load bank rental company)
  6. Oregon Department of Energy, New Construction Commissioning Handbook for Facility Managers
  7. AABC Commissioning Group (ACG), “For Building Owners”
  8. HUB International (a broker), “Professional Construction Services Insurance”
  9. EJCDC, Contract Insurability Negotiation Guide
  10. EPIC Insurance Brokers (a broker), “Three top data center construction risks”
  11. Summit (a Canadian broker), “Builders risk and installation floater: testing and commissioning”
  12. HUB International (a broker), “Data Center Insurance and Risk Management”

General information only, not legal advice, current as of November 2026. Commissioning level definitions vary by firm and project. Whether a loss is covered depends on the policy wording and the facts. Have counsel review your contract.

Talk to a specialist

Tell Us About Your Firm. We’ll Tell You What We See.

Starting out or renewing, with a policy in hand or not. If something is worth discussing, we’ll call. If not, we’ll say so.