Short answer
A basis of design document liability question starts when a system underperforms and someone says “design error.” The first issue is whether the design was wrong or the conditions exceeded what it was designed for. The documented basis of design answers that: the standard you designed to, the outdoor and indoor design conditions, and any owner requirements above the minimum. If it is written down and the owner approved it, you are in a much stronger position. Whether a policy responds depends on its wording and the facts.
Error vs. conditions
A design error is a mistake. Examples include a missed load, a math error or a wrong code reference. The design fails because someone got something wrong.
A condition beyond the design is different. The engineer designs to a recognized standard and a stated set of conditions. Later, the system faces weather or use that exceeds those conditions. The design may perform exactly as intended and still fall short of what the owner expected.
Owners and contractors often use one word, “error,” for both situations. The distinction matters because it shapes who pays for a fix and how an insurer views the dispute. Whether a design met the standard of care depends on the facts and the contract.
Our article on when the client says the HVAC does not work shows how a comfort complaint can escalate.
What a basis of design document should state
A basis of design records the criteria behind the design. It gives anyone reviewing the project a clear reference. A useful document usually states:
- The standard or code the design follows
- Indoor design conditions, such as temperature and humidity targets
- Outdoor design conditions, such as the weather data used
- Key assumptions about use, occupancy and equipment
- Owner requirements, especially those above the minimum
- Known limitations of the design
The ASHRAE site offers guidance on commissioning and owner’s project requirements, which often feed into this document. Keep it short and specific. A document that states numbers and sources is more useful than one that states general intentions.
Have the owner review and approve it in writing. Approval turns the document from an internal note into a shared reference.
Owner expectations above the minimum
Some owners want more margin than the standard requires. They may prefer tighter temperature control or extra capacity for extreme days. That preference is reasonable, but it should appear in writing.
If an owner asks for more, record the request and design to it. Price the added work and say so in the agreement. An owner who never asked for extra capacity may later argue the design should have included it. A written record shows what the owner requested and approved.
When an owner wants more than was originally designed, the added cost raises a separate question about betterment. Our article on betterment explains how those costs are usually treated.